I grew up in a somewhat religious household. While I am not a bible thumping Christian who feels the need to preach from the street corner, I do have my beliefs and they have been a large part of my life ever since I was born. So while I was reading Tomasulo’s article, I really began to feel uncomfortable as he started pointing out the religious symbols and
![]() |
| http://eddyrivas.com/2010/06/09/movies-that-need-to-be-on-blu-ray/ |
On an unrelated note, a lot of film analysts want to label the man with the keys as a father figure. I disagree. To me, that man is just another character who’s purpose is to provide suspense in the scenes before he reveals is face, and to act as an understanding friend towards Elliott when he finally does reveal himself. The man provides suspense because we never see his face and his keys prove him to be a man of authority. He is obviously looking for E.T. throughout the film, but the ominous music makes it seem like he could want to hurt him. When we finally see his face, the man is basically just excited that aliens exist. He wants to help E.T. and understands how much he means to Elliott. While the other adults may not listen to Elliott because he is “just a kid,” the could listen to this man because he is an adult. The idea that he is a father figure seems pointless to me.
Overall, E.T. really is a great film and is enjoyable to watch. Especially when you watch it as a work of fiction, instead of over analyzing it and comparing E.T. to Jesus...

I agree with you about the man with they keys. I was confused when people were saying he was their father or father figure. I did not get that from the movie at all. I just thought he was a creepy man that was hunting aliens. He is a man of authority but definitely not father figure. I think the tid bits about Elliot's father being gone were unnecessary, although divorce was a cultural anxiety of the time.
ReplyDeleteI think a lot of what was in the article was far fetched. When someone sees something they truly believe they will stop at nothing to keep linking these so called Jesus coincidences. Yes there were some, but Frank got a little out of hand much like a conspiracy nut. I do agree with the man with the keys not being a father figure for the film. He was just a man looking for aliens and by not showing his face it made it that much more suspenseful. I was almost expecting the cigarette man from the X Files to be the man with the keys (which would have made the film a billion times better.)
ReplyDeleteI'd really like you to explore why, of all things, the comparison of Jesus to an alien was the thing that bugged you? Consider how he was treated by just about everybody. Plus, he quite literally was not of this earth. I think our best analyses comes out of the things that bug us--because those are the places of perception. Also, why does the idea of Keys (he's really named Keys) as a father figure bother you? He definitely wasn't some random dude. He bonded with Elliot, said he shared the same longing for a miracle since he was 10, and ended up with his arm around Mary, Ellott's mom. The thing about this movie that's so disturbing though, is that all male authority figures are deeply creepy (even avuncular ones), and Mary (as if the symbolism wasn't heavyhanded enough) was a really helpless, distracted sort of mother. Those things were pretty obvious, and it's absolutely certain that Spielberg did it on purpose. What I'm not sure about is Tomasulo's argument that Spielberg was somehow buying into or advancing the message of the religious Right--though he also seemed to back away from that argument some in favor of placing the Christ imagery within the larger Hero pattern as outlined by Campbell.
ReplyDelete